"Fine."
There is a photograph of me sitting next to my baby brother.
I look inexplicably on edge.
My expression hard to read.
Can a person look quiet in a photograph?
I look tense, pale and so, so still.
He is furious.
Red faced, mid wail, fists already clenched tight enough to turn his knuckles white,
like this brand new world had already offended him personally.
Seated together we almost look choreographed,
yin and yang,
opposites in a diagram.
He is volume.
I am silence.
He was “colicky",
a polite word for relentless.
He cried in long, unbroken stretches that made the world squeeze in on me.
He didn't just throw food off his high chair,
he launched it - at furniture, at the walls,
sometimes at me.
He pulled books off of the shelves.
Destroyed things with the confidence of someone who dares the world to respond.
He was my baby brother and it all slid together into a predictable stereotype of a sibling.
Especially a younger one.
He couldn't help himself.
I remember my mom.
She was always right at the edge of something.
She broadcast tremors and tension,
the kind of anxiety that could make a person cry or scream.
She was always scanning.
Cowering from something she never named
and I never saw.
She felt distant, unreadable.
With a vague air of loss
waiting around the wrong turn.
Sometimes she also had a sharpness that flashed brighter and more frightening than anything I had ever seen.
It would fold me in on myself in an instant.
Like a drying rack or a stepping stool that collapses to be stored when they're not needed.
She loved us, I know that.
But she was barely hanging on.
Or maybe she raised us in perpetual free fall.
Our house was nice,
our home was more traitorous.
No one assigned me the role of easy.
He screamed.
She unraveled.
I volunteered.
He needed.
She cried.
I recalibrated.
You don’t have to be told to disappear.
You just notice there isn’t room for you anymore.
Your emotions become flat and now you're "fine".
Eventually, fine becomes more than a thing you say because no one is listening anyway.
You embody "fine".
Fine is the child who can play alone.
Fine is the one who intuits boundaries instead of testing them.
Fine knows that love is already overextended and adjusts her appetite accordingly.
Fine knows her preferences are optional and a burden on others.
Fine is "an easy kid".
Years later, I am drinking in ways that look almost normal from the outside.
Not falling down.
Not burning bridges.
Still articulate. Still productive. Still the one who's not burdening family or friends.
Fine.
Inside, though, there is a constant, low grade negotiation:
How much space am I allowed to fill before the room tightens?
Alcohol solves this temporarily.
It blurs the edges of the question.
But the blur has a price,
and I pay it unquestioningly.
Dignity.
Independence.
Self respect.
All to avoid the question -
"How much of myself can be seen before I'm abandoned?"
The fork in the road does not arrive with sirens.
It arrives as a sentence.
"You could just go."
Not theatrically.
Not to be found.
Just - go somewhere alone and finish it.
The sentence is disturbingly calm.
It does not feel impulsive.
It feels tidy, gentle.
A way to stop being the adjustable one by removing myself entirely.
No more calibrating.
No more proving I'm low maintenance.
No more managing how much oxygen I breathe.
It feels like rest after a long journey.
The other sentence arrives almost as an afterthought.
"Or you could go to rehab."
The symmetry of it unsettles me even now.
One path: disappear quietly.
One path: admit you are not fine.
Both feel like detonations.
I have tried to reconstruct the moment when one option outweighed the other.
I cannot pin it down.
There was no cinematic intervention.
No beam of light coming down from above.
No booming voice providing The Answer.
There was just a subtle resistance.
Like trying to step into traffic and discovering your legs won’t move.
Not because you’re brave.
Because something has stalled.
I still don’t know if that something was instinct, cowardice, love, fear, or what people mean when they say grace.
I don’t know if I was truly capable of the first option.
I only know I didn’t take it.
Instead, I told my husband I wanted to go to rehab,
and not to let me get out of it.
In early sobriety, people asked how I was doing.
“Fine,” I said.
Which was almost funny.
Because "fine" had nearly escorted me out of my own life.
Fine had whispered that I was too much trouble to keep.
Fine had offered a solution that caused the least disruption to everyone else while taking everything from me.
And that felt fair.
My daughter is loud.
Messy.
She slams doors. She screams when she is angry. She occupies space with the naive confidence of a toddler.
It's not that she believes all the space in every room belongs to her,
she's just never had to negotiate for it.
Sometimes her noise makes my body brace.
Not because she is wrong.
Because I remember what it feels like when there isn't much space left.
I can feel the balloon about to pop,
tension,
and I am the little girl in the picture again.
I am determined not to teach her to fold.
What I don't know is how to unfold myself.
At night, I still stand outside her door sometimes.
She is asleep.
The house is safe.
The heater clicks to life and warm air comes hissing in.
No one is throwing books or expletives.
No one is crying in the bathroom.
No one is here,
so I can come out of hiding.
And yet my nervous system hums like it’s waiting for impact.
Sobriety did not still the humming.
It welcomed it back into the limelight.
The girl in the photograph sits carefully beside a screaming baby.
Like a small bird perched on a thin branch, ready to take flight should the wind come.
Bracing to flee to avoid being hurt.
And yet, the girl in the picture looks composed.
"Fine."
I want to tell her that fine is not the same as safe.
That one day she will nearly mistake composure for clarity.
That she will almost choose permanent darkness because it seems efficient.
I want to tell her she doesn’t have to make herself smaller than the noise.
But I don’t know if she would believe me.
I chose rehab.
I am still choosing it.
I don’t fully understand why I am here instead of gone.
Sometimes I think it was strength.
Sometimes I think it was an accident.
Sometimes I think something - not outside me exactly, but not entirely me either - leaned on the scale by a fraction of an inch.
Not enough to be declared miraculous.
Just enough.
The house hums with domestic tranquility.
My daughter scribbles shapes on a notebook.
My husband is baking.
I am still here.
Not resolved.
Not convinced that I won't be tempted again by the efficiency of disappearing.
Instead I'm still here,
trying to breathe.
Learning to embody confidence instead of quiet.
Confidence in myself,
in existence.
That the family I love won't disappear just because I start taking up space.
That quiet isn't a warning.
That someone can love me
and still be angry with me.
That true love doesn’t require me to disappear inside it.
My daughter screams.
My husband closes the cabinet a little too hard.
BAM!
Every muscle in my body clenches.
Most of all,
I'm learning to say the words -
"I'm not fine."


Oh my god there is so much here I want to talk to you about. You covered so much with such grace. Somehow grace and also that "oof" stomach punch of truth. I had an older brother but I find I relate more to people with younger siblings. He had anger problems and behavior problems that clashed with my dad and pushed everyone's buttons. All I wanted to do was be invisible and you described all of that perfectly. There was a lot more that got me but a big one was how your whole body clenches when your daughter screams or. your husband slams a cabinet door. I HATE that. I am trying so hard to breathe and not let every little thing send me into fight or flight but...it is so so hard. I am so happy you are continuing to share your stories.
This is astoundingly beautiful. I am utterly amazed when I come across a writer who shows rawness and honesty like this - it flaws the reader. It makes us think about it long after we’ve stopped reading. I hope you continue to take up space with your writing here. You have so much of value to say.